Friday, 22 May 2020

A Servey Report  : Coronavirus sparks a sanitary pad crisis in India: Sanjay Patil

A Servey Report : Coronavirus sparks a sanitary pad crisis in India: Sanjay Patil

Students listen to a lecture on menstrual health and hygiene on December 17, 2018 in Pune


Schoolgirls in India are facing a massive shortage of sanitary napkins because schools - a critical part of the supply chain - are closed during the coronavirus lockdown. This has left millions of teenagers across the country anxious. 


Sanjay Patil : Nagpur Press Media : BBC :  22 May 2020 :For the past several years, Priya has been receiving a pack of 10 sanitary napkins every month from her school.
The 14-year-old, who lives in Badli, a slum in northwest Delhi, attends a state-run school where pads are distributed to all female students in middle and senior school under a government scheme to promote menstrual hygiene.
It's an important campaign in a country where only 36% of its 355 million menstruating females use napkins (the remaining use old cloth, rags, husk or ash to manage the flow) and nearly 23 million girls drop out of school annually after they start their periods.
But, with schools shut because of the lockdown, the supply of pads too has stopped.
"I got my last pack in February," says Priya. "Since then, I have had to buy them from the local chemist. I have to pay 30 rupees ($0.40;£0.30) for a pack of seven napkins."
Priya considers herself lucky that her parents can still pay for her to buy pads. Many of her neighbours have lost their jobs in the lockdown and can't even afford food. Girls in those families have had to start using rags.
Just a few miles from Priya's home in Badli is Bhalaswa Dairy, a slum that's home to around 1,900 families. Madhu Bala Rawat, an activist who lives and works in the area, has also flagged the shortage of sanitary napkins for schoolgirls.
"Periods don't stop during a pandemic. Pads are essential for women, like food. Why does the government ignore our requirement," she asks?
Most girls in the slum, including her 14-year-old daughter, are dependent on the supply from their school because they can't afford to buy sanitary napkins, she says.
"The girls are worried, how will they deal with their periods now? They don't like to use cloth anymore because they have become used to disposable napkins. The government should supply it with the monthly ration."
After Ms Rawat sent out an SOS, Womenite, a charity that works on menstrual hygiene, distributed 150 packs of sanitary napkins in Badli and Bhalaswa Dairy in April.
Harshit Gupta, founder of Womenite, says they have raised funds to distribute 100,000 more packs in Delhi and some surrounding districts in May to coincide with international menstrual hygiene day on the 28th.
"We'll start distributions in the next few days," he told the BBC.
There have been other similar initiatives across India.
One sanitary napkin manufacturer distributed 80,000 pads in Delhi and Punjab.
And police in cities like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Jaipur, Chandigarh, Bhubaneshwar and Kolkata have been roped in to hand them out to residents of slums as well as stranded migrants in relief camps.
On Monday, India's governing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) announced it would be giving 600,000 packs to police to distribute among adolescent girls and women in Delhi slums.
But it's not just the cities. The shortage of pads is being felt across the country and the problem is much more acute in semi-urban and rural areas, says Shailja Mehta, who works on issues of adolescents at Dasra, a philanthropic organisation.
"During our conversations with our partners in several states, we heard that only 15% girls had access to sanitary napkins during the lockdown.
"With schools shut, the girls are getting pads only through the community health workers who are handing over whatever little supplies they have."
The problem started when India first imposed a country-wide lockdown on 25 March, and sanitary napkins were not in the list of essential items which were exempt from restrictions.
It was only on 29 March, after reports that chemists, grocery stores and online sites were running out of pads, that the government added sanitary napkins to the list of essentials. The delay caused nearly 10 days of production loss.
"After the government allowed us to operate, it took us another three to four days to restart the factories because we had to get all the required permissions and passes for our workers," Rajesh Shah, president of Feminine and Infant Hygiene Association of India, told the BBC.
Mr Shah says production is still partially resumed because there's an acute shortage of workers who have fled the cities for their villages.
"Only 60% of the factories are operational and not one is operating at full capacity. There is a shortage of workers, factories in 'containment zones' are not allowed to open, and there are massive disruptions in the supply and distribution chain."
There's a massive shortage of sanitary napkins, he says and warns that the situation will get worse before it gets better.
Tanya Mahajan of the Menstrual Health Alliance of India (MHAI), a network of NGOs, manufacturers and experts that works to create awareness about periods, says their partners from across the country have reported "significant disruptions" in supplies, especially in remote rural areas.
"The first to suffer is always the last mile," she says.
"In remote villages, where pads are not available in the local store, people have to go to the nearest town or district centre which could be 10-40kms away. Also at present, there is limited mobility because of social distancing and a lack of public transport."
And most girls may not be comfortable asking men in the family to procure pads for them since periods is a taboo subject not openly talked about in Indian families.
As a result, Ms Mahajan says, many adolescent girls who were dependent on getting supplies from their schools, have started using cloth pads.
Considering that India uses a billion pads a month and the plastic in the disposable pads means they are not biodegradable, campaigners say reusable products such as menstrual cups and cloth pads are a much more sustainable alternative.
Irrespective of what is used, says Arundati Muralidharan of WaterAid charity, it is essential to ensure hygiene - reusable cloth pads must always be cotton, they must be washed properly and dried in the sun before being reused.
It may sound simple, but is not so easy to achieve.
In slums, when all the men are at home because of the lockdown, girls and women may find it difficult to use toilet facilities as frequently as they like and in villages, getting additional water to wash pads and put them out in the sun to dry could be difficult.
"Many of our partner organisations say women and adolescent health has taken a backseat during the Covid-19 crisis and it's important to address that," Ms Muralidharan says.

Menstrual Hygiene Day Facts: Only 36 Percent Of The Women In India Use Sanitary Pads During Periods

May 28 is observed as Menstrual Hygiene Day globally

 Menstruation is normal and a healthy part of life and yet girls and women in India go through extreme struggles to manage their period every month. A large chuck of the Indian population believes this natural cycle to be a ‘curse’, ‘impure’ and ‘dirty’ among other things, courtesy of the ancient myths surrounding menstruation in our country. According to Census 2011 population data, about 336 million girls and women in India are of reproductive age and menstruate for 2-7 days, every month, and yet the topic of menstruation is expected to be a hush affair and kept under wraps of the ‘black plastic bags’, which is given to most of us each time we buy sanitary napkins.
When a girl faces challenges in managing her period in a healthy manner, it can cause a number of problems to her physical as well as mental health. Not only will she be at risk of infection, but her education, self-esteem, and confidence also suffer in a major way. May 28 is observed as Menstrual Hygiene Day globally, so to mark this day, let’s look at some stark facts about menstruation in India that you should know. Period.

1. Only 36 Percent Women Use Sanitary Pads In India

National Family Health Survey 2015-2016 estimates that of the 336 million menstruating women in India about 121 million (roughly 36 percent) women are using sanitary napkins, locally or commercially produced.

2. Sanitary napkins: The Impact on Environment

Most common menstrual hygiene product in India is sanitary napkin which is disposable and they can have an adverse impact on the environment due to the huge amounts of plastics they contain.
Dr. Surbhi Singh, Delhi-based Gynaecologist and a menstrual hygiene activist says,
Conventional sanitary pads and tampons available in the market are loaded with plastic. These menstrual products are used for at least 4-6 days per month by most women worldwide. This means a huge amount of plastic waste is generated every month globally. After being disposed of, sanitary products that are usually made out of plastic take over 500 years to break down.
WaterAid India, a non-profit organisation, stresses on the need to find sustainable alternates to menstrual hygiene practices in India, as it has estimated that of this 121 million girls and women dispose of about 21,780 million pads annually, which poses a major threat to the country’s waste management crisis. The alternatives to sanitary napkins could be menstrual cups, tampons and eco-friendly sanitary pads.

3. What Exactly Happens Due To Poor Menstrual Hygiene?

We often hear that unhygienic period health and disposal practices can have major consequences on the health of women, but what exactly is at risk here? Every person – male or female should be aware of the diseases that could be caused if a woman does not have access to menstrual hygiene products. The issue can increase a woman’s chances of contracting cervical cancer, Reproductive Tract Infections, Hepatitis B infection, various types of yeast infections and Urinary Tract Infection, to name a few.

4. How Informed Are Young Girls Who Are Yet To Menstruate?

A 2016 study titled – ‘Menstrual hygiene management among adolescent girls in India’ involving nearly 100,000 girls in India found that almost 50,000 did not know about menstruation until the first time they got their period. The study further explains how many girls even think that they are dying or have caught a horrible disease, the first time they menstruate, due to the pain and blood.

5. Menstruation And Impact On Education

A 2014 report by the NGO Dasra titled ‘Spot On!’ informed that almost 23 million girls in India drop out of school annually, because of lack of menstrual hygiene management facilities, including availability of sanitary napkins and awareness about menstruation. The report further suggests that the girls, who don’t drop out, usually miss up to 5 days of school every month.

23 Million Women Drop Out Of School Every Year When They Start Menstruating In India

23 Million Women Drop Out Of School Every Year When They Start Menstruating In India

It was the occasion of an annual function at a secondary school in Rajasthan’s Dholpur district in May 2017. Manoj Kumar, the district health officer was one of the dignitaries invited to the function. While giving a short speech on the importance of education, Mr Kumar noticed the alarmingly low number of girls present in the crowd of school students. On enquiring further, he was told that many girls drop out of school on reaching the sixth or seventh standard as they reach puberty. In a remote district like Dholpur, a primary school is barely equipped with a functional toilet, let alone something as essential as sanitary napkin dispensers. But more than the infrastructure for young girls in Dholpur, like millions of others in districts, towns and cities across India, menstruation remains a biological event shrouded in mystery and taboo, not to be spoken about openly.
355 million is the number of menstruating women in India, accounting for nearly 30 per cent of the country’s population. Menstruation continues to be a subject of gender disparity in India. Myths about menstruation are largely prevalent, forcing many girls to drop out of school early or be ostracised for the duration of their menstrual cycle every month. A 2014 report by the NGO Dasra titled Spot On! found that nearly 23 million girls drop out of school annually due to lack of proper menstrual hygiene management facilities, which include availability of sanitary napkins and logical awareness of menstruation. The report also came up with some startling numbers. 70 per cent of mothers with menstruating daughters considered menstruation as dirty and 71 per cent adolescent girls remained unaware of menstruation till menarche. A 2014 UNICEF report pointed out that in Tamil Nadu, 79 per cent girls and women were unaware of menstrual hygiene practices. The percentage was 66% in Uttar Pradesh, 56% in Rajasthan and 51% in West Bengal.
The problems with menstruation in India are that they are similar to a chain of command, related to each other. There is no awareness on menstruation, hence it is considered dirty. Being a ‘dirty’ occurrence, a menstruating girl is isolated or forced to drop out of school as unlike urban areas, access to sanitary napkins in rural areas is low. This cycle is handed over from mother to daughter but the taboo on menstruation remains, said Meenakshi Sharma, Coordinator for Menstrual Hygiene Management, WASH Alliance.
Lack of Awareness
Lack of awareness makes for a major problem in India’s menstrual hygiene scenario. Indian Council for Medical Research’s 2011-12 report stated that only 38 per cent menstruating girls in India spoke to their mothers about menstruation. Many mothers were themselves unaware what menstruation was, how it was to be explained to a teenager and what practices could be considered as menstrual hygiene management. Schools were not very helpful either as schools in rural areas refrained from discussing menstrual hygiene. A 2015 survey by the Ministry of Education found that in 63% schools in villages, teachers never discussed menstruation and how to deal with it in a hygienic manner.
Women across India grow up remaining unaware of the real reasons for menstruation and the importance of menstrual hygiene. The taboo surrounding menstruation remains a part of their growing up and continues with their daughters. Hence, the lack of awareness is carried forward via generations in India, said Supriya Khanna of Indian Council for Medical Research.
Lack of Sanitary Napkins and Adequate Facilities
In a city, availing a sanitary napkin for a woman aware of menstrual hygiene is a normalised process. Not only are sanitary napkins available in pharmacies and grocery stores in cities, they are commercialised via advertisements so that they are treated as any other product. In rural areas, sanitary napkins are found with difficulty. Most girls rely on home-grown or other readily available material, the latter often being unhygienic and unsanitary. Only 2 to 3 per cent women in rural India are estimated to use sanitary napkins. The lack of demand results in storekeepers not stocking up on sanitary pads. This results in women resorting to unhygienic practices during their menstrual cycle, such as filling up old socks with sand and tying them around waists to absorb menstrual blood, or taking up old pieces of cloth and using them to absorb blood. Such methods increase chances of infection and hinder the day-to-day task of a woman on her period.
It has been seen in rural areas that two-three women of the same family use the same cloth during menstruation, after washing and drying it. This is extremely unhealthy and brings numerous health risks. Sanitary napkins are a luxury in rural areas and small towns. Even if available, women are discouraged from spending on sanitary napkins as old clothes or sand is thought to be good enough for something ‘dirty’ like menstruation, said Ms Sharma.
Impact on Women’s Health
Surveys by the Ministry of Health in 2002, 2005, 2008 and 2012 found out that most problems related to menstrual hygiene in India are preventable, but are not due to low awareness and poor menstrual hygiene management. This resulted in development of some serious ailments for adolescent girls. Roughly 120 million menstruating adolescents in India experience menstrual dysfunctions, affecting their normal daily chores. Nearly 60,000 cases of cervical cancer deaths are reported every year from India, two-third of which are due to poor menstrual hygiene.
Other health problems associated with menstrual hygiene like anaemia, prolonged or short periods, infections of reproductive tracts, as well as psychological problems such as anxiety, embarrassment and shame.
Menstruation is such a taboo subject that many women are ashamed even to seek medical advice if they face any health problems due to menstruation. Unhygienic menstrual conditions often result in women developing health problems which are further aggravated due to their inability to seek medical help on time, said Sahana Bhat, Co-founder of the NGO Sukhibhava which works in the field of menstrual hygiene. 
Government Schemes On Menstrual Hygiene
From a ban on advertisements on sanitary napkins in 1990, to a full-fledged feature film, PadMan, on a low-cost sanitary napkin entrepreneur in 2018, India has indeed come a long way. It was eight years back in 2010, when the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare launched the Freeday Pad Scheme, a pilot project to provide sanitary napkins at subsidised rates for rural girls. The scheme was launched in 152 districts across 20 states and sanitary napkins were sold to adolescent girls at the rate of R
s.
 6 per pack of six napkins by Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs). The estimated cost for the entire scheme was R
s.
 70 crore.

A year later, the Union government launched the SABLA scheme across 2015 districts in the country. The scheme aimed at improving health conditions for adolescent girls with menstrual hygiene as an important component. Two years later, under the then ongoing Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan, focus on menstrual hygiene was added as a key component of the sanitation mission. In 2014, the Union government launched the Rashtriya Kishor Swashthya Karyakram, aimed at improving the health and hygiene of an estimated 243 million adolescents. Menstrual hygiene was also included as an integral part of the programme.
Under the ongoing Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, menstrual hygiene has been given high importance. The Swachh Bharat (Gramin) guidelines explicitly state that funds allocated for information, education and communication (IEC) maybe spent on bettering awareness on menstrual hygiene in villages. Adequate knowledge of menstrual hygiene and development of local sanitary napkin manufacturing units is encouraged by Swachh Bharat Mission (rural) and self-help groups are to help in propagating such efforts.
Menstrual hygiene is an integral part of ensuring better sanitation in rural villages. Construction of toilets in households and schools is integral to menstrual hygiene. Under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, we are encouraging safe menstrual hygiene practices. Skill development and setting up of sanitary napkin dispensers and incinerators in schools and public toilets is a prime component of the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, said Arun Baroka, Joint Secretary, Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation.
Recently, Union Minister for Drinking Water and Sanitation Uma Bharti said that sanitary napkin, similar to a toilet, is a right of every woman. Reiterating that menstrual hygiene was a key concern for the ministry, Ms Bharti at a recent press conference said that she spoke to Union Minister for Textile Smriti Irani and Union Minister for Woman and Child Development Maneka Gandhi on making affordable sanitary napkins available to women in rural areas.
Looking Ahead: An India With Proper Menstrual Hygiene
“The myths and taboos surrounding menstruation need to be broken down effectively before schemes and incentives make their way to make life better for menstruating women,” said a WaterAid India official.
Conditions for menstruating women in India can only improve when awareness on menstrual hygiene is spread. IEC on menstrual hygiene, under Swachh Bharat Abhiyan or any other state scheme must educate women across all ages on what menstruation is and why the taboos surrounding it do tremendous harm. Simultaneously, sanitary napkins must be provided to menstruating women to ensure that they do not fall prey to age old unhygienic traditions of using cloth, soil or sand. It must be remembered that 88% of India’s menstruating women do not use sanitary napkins. Making sanitary napkins available to over 300 million women and ensuring that they do use these will be a herculean task, and can only be achieved with due cooperation all stakeholders and proper coordination between them to improve the status menstrual hygiene in India.

'Period-shaming' Indian college forces students to strip to underwear

A wall painting about menstruation in Guwahati on May 28, 2019
College students living in a hostel in the western Indian state of Gujarat have complained that they were made to strip and show their underwear to female teachers to prove that they were not menstruating.
The 68 young women were pulled out of classrooms and taken to the toilet, where they were asked to individually remove their knickers for inspection.
The incident took place in the city of Bhuj on Tuesday. The young women are undergraduate students at Shree Sahajanand Girls Institute (SSGI), which is run by Swaminarayan sect, a wealthy and conservative Hindu religious group.
They said a hostel official had complained to the college principal on Monday that some of the students were breaking rules menstruating women are supposed to follow.
According to these rules, women are barred from entering the temple and the kitchen and are not allowed to touch other students during their periods.
At meal times, they have to sit away from others, they have to clean their own dishes, and in the classroom, they are expected to sit on the last bench.
One of the students told BBC Gujarati's Prashant Gupta that the hostel maintains a register where they are expected to enter their names when they get their periods, which helps the authorities to identify them.
But for the past two months, not one student had entered her name in the register - perhaps not surprising considering the restrictions they have to put up with if they do.
So on Monday, the hostel official complained to the principal that menstruating students were entering the kitchen, going near the temple, and mingling with other hostellers.
The students allege that, the next day, they were abused by the hostel official and the principal before they were forced to strip.
They described what happened to them as a "very painful experience" that had left them "traumatised" and amounted to "mental torture".
One student's father said that when he arrived at the college, his daughter and several other students came to him and started crying. "They are in shock," he said.
On Thursday, a group of students held a protest on the campus, demanding action against the college officials who had "humiliated" them.
The college trustee Pravin Pindoria said the incident was "unfortunate", adding that an investigation had been ordered and action would be taken against anyone found guilty of wrongdoing.
But Darshana Dholakia, the vice-chancellor of the university which the college is affiliated with, put the blame on the students. She said that they had broken rules and added that some of them had apologised.
However, some of the students told BBC Gujarati that they are now under pressure from the school authorities to play down the incident and not to speak of their ordeal.
On Friday, the Gujarat State Women's Commission ordered an investigation into this "shameful exercise" and asked the students to "come forward and speak without fear about their grievances". The police have lodged a complaint.
This is not the first time that female students have been humiliated on account of periods.
In a very similar case, 70 students were stripped naked three years ago at a residential school in northern India by the female warden after she found blood on a bathroom door.
Discrimination against women on account of menstruation is widespread in India, where periods have long been a taboo and menstruating women are considered impure. They are often excluded from social and religious events, denied entry into temples and shrines and kept out of kitchens.
Increasingly, urban educated women have been challenging these regressive ideas. In the past few years, attempts have been made to see periods for just what they are - a natural biological function.
But success has been patchy.
In 2018, the top court in a landmark order threw open the doors of the Sabarimala shrine to women of all ages, saying that keeping women out of the temple in the southern state of Kerala was discriminatory.
But a year later, the judges agreed to review the order after massive protests in the state.
Surprisingly, the protesters included a large number of women - an indication of how deeply rooted the stigma over menstruation is.

Why are menstruating women in India removing their wombs?

Periods have long been a taboo in the country, menstruating women are believed to be impure and are still excluded from social and religious events. In recent years, these archaic ideas have been increasingly challenged, especially by urban educated women.
But two recent reports show that India's very problematic relationship with menstruation continues. A vast majority of women, especially those from poor families, with no agency and no education, are forced to make choices that have long-term and irreversible impacts on their health and their lives.
The first comes from the western state of Maharashtra where it has been revealed by Indian media that thousands of young women have undergone surgical procedures to remove their wombs in the past three years. In a substantial number of cases they have done this so they can get work as sugarcane harvesters.
Every year, tens of thousands of poor families from Beed, Osmanabad, Sangli and Solapur districts migrate to more affluent western districts of the state - known as "the sugar belt" - to work for six months as "cutters" in sugarcane fields.
Once there, they are at the mercy of greedy contractors who use every opportunity to exploit them.
To begin with, they are reluctant to hire women because cane-cutting is hard work and women may miss a day or two of work during their periods. If they do miss a day's work, they have to pay a penalty.
The living conditions at their work-place are far from ideal - the families have to live in huts or tents close to the fields, there are no toilets, and as harvesting is sometimes done even at night, there is no fixed time for sleeping or waking. And when women get their periods, it just becomes that much more tough for them.
Because of the poor hygienic conditions, many women catch infections and, activists working in the region say, unscrupulous doctors encourage them to undergo unnecessary surgery even if they visit for a minor gynaecological problem which can be treated with medicine.
As most women in these areas are married young, many have two to three children by the time they are in their mid-20s, and because doctors don't tell them about the problems they would face if they underwent a hysterectomy, many believe that it's OK to get rid of their wombs.
This has turned several villages in the region into "villages of womb-less women".
After the issue was raised last month in the state assembly by legislator Neelam Gorhe, Maharashtra Health Minister Eknath Shinde admitted that there had been 4,605 hysterectomies just in Beed district in three years. But, he said, not all of them were carried out on women who worked as sugarcane harvesters. The minister said a committee had been set up to investigate several of the cases.
My colleague Prajakta Dhulap from the BBC's Marathi language service, who visited Vanjarwadi village in Beed district, says from October to March every year, 80% of villagers migrate to work in sugarcane fields. She reports that half of the women in the village have had hysterectomies - most are under the age of 40 and some are still in their 20s.
Many of the women she met said their health had deteriorated since they underwent surgery. One woman talked about the "persistent pain in her back, neck and knee" and how she wakes up in the morning with "swollen hands, face and feet". Another complained of "constant dizziness" and how she was unable to walk even short distances. As a result, they both said they were no longer able to work in the fields.
According to a Thomson Reuters Foundation expose, based on interviews with about 100 women, the drugs were rarely provided by medical professionals and the seamstresses, mostly from poor disadvantaged families, said they couldn't afford to lose a day's wages on account of period pains.
All of the 100 women who were interviewed said they had received drugs, and more than half said that as a result, their health had suffered.
Most said they were not told the name of the drugs or warned about any possible side-effects.
Many of the women blamed these medicines for their health problems, ranging from depression and anxiety, to urinary tract infections, fibroids and miscarriages.
The reports have forced the authorities into action. The National Commission for Women has described the condition of the women in Maharashtra as "pathetic and miserable" and asked the state government to prevent such "atrocities" in future. In Tamil Nadu, the government said they would monitor the health of the garment workers.
The reports come at a time when attempts are being made across the world to increase women's participation in the workforce by implementing gender-sensitive policies.
Worryingly, female workforce participation in India has fallen from 36% in 2005-06 to 25.8% in 2015-16 and it's not hard to understand why if we look at the conditions in which women have to work.
In Indonesia, Japan, South Korea and a few other countries, women are allowed a day off work during their periods. Many private companies also offer similar relief.
"In India too, the Bihar state government has been allowing women employees to take two extra days off every month since as far back as 1992 and it seems to be working very well," says Urvashi Prasad, a public policy specialist at the Indian government think tank, Niti Aayog.
And last year, a female MP tabled a Menstrual Benefits Bill in the parliament, seeking two days off every month for every working woman in the country.
Ms Prasad says there are challenges to implementing any policy in a vast country like India, especially in the informal sector where it needs much more monitoring. But, she says, if a start is made in the formal sector, it can signal a change in mindsets and help remove the stigma that surrounds menstruation in India.
"So what we need is for the powerful organised private sector and the government to take a stand, we need people at the top to send the right signals," she says. "We have to start somewhere and eventually we can expect to see some change in the unorganised sector too."
The Menstrual Benefits Bill is a private member's bill so it's unlikely that it will come to much, but if it does become law, it would likely benefit the women who work in Tamil Nadu's garment factories which will have to implement it.
But such welfare measures rarely benefit those employed in India's vast unorganised sector, which means that women like those working in Maharashtra's sugarcane fields will remain at the mercy of their contractors.

Why are Indian women 'Happy to Bleed'?

A woman holds a #HappyToBleed poster

Menstruation is generally a taboo topic in India, something that is rarely talked about openly.
But at the weekend, several photographs popped up on my Facebook page of young Indian women holding placards - some made up of sanitary napkins and tampons - with the slogan "Happy To Bleed".
A little bit of research led me to this petition, started by college student Nikita Azad, who was annoyed by the sexist remarks made by the head of the famous Sabarimala temple in Kerala.
"A time will come when people will ask if all women should be disallowed from entering the temple throughout the year," Prayar Gopalakrishnan, who recently took charge of the hilltop temple dedicated to Lord Ayyappa, told reporters earlier this month.
"These days there are machines that can scan bodies and check for weapons. There will be a day when a machine is invented to scan if it is the 'right time' for a woman to enter the temple. When that machine is invented, we will talk about letting women inside," he added.
Ms Azad insists that there is no "right time" to go into a temple and that women should have to right to go "wherever they want to and whenever they want to".
The temple priest's comments, she says, reinforce misogyny and strengthen the myths that revolve around women, and that "Happy To Bleed" is a counter-campaign against menstrual taboos.
Hinduism regards menstruating women as unclean so, during her periods, a woman is not allowed to enter the temple, touch any idols, enter the kitchen or even touch the pickle jar.
Many Hindu temples in India - and also globally - have prominent notices displayed at the entrance telling menstruating women that they are not welcome, and many devout Hindu women voluntarily keep away from temples when they are menstruating.
But the Sabarimala bars all women in the reproductive age from entering the temple.
The temple website explains that as Lord Ayyappa was "Nithya Brahmachari - or celibate - women between the 10-50 age group are not allowed to enter Sabarimala".
The website adds, rather threateningly, that "such women who try to enter Sabarimala will be prevented by (the) authorities" from doing so.
Ms Azad says "we don't believe in religion that considers half the world impure" and that theirs is "not a temple-entry campaign" - it's "a protest against patriarchy and gender discriminatory practices prevalent in our society" and that they are fighting against sexism and age-old taboos.
Since its launch on Saturday, #HappyToBleed has received a lot of responses, especially from young urban Indian women.
"More than 100 women have posted their photographs on Facebook holding banners and placards, with catchy slogans, and many more have shared these photos on their timelines," Ms Azad told the BBC.
The campaign has also been picked up by many people on Twitter who have written in with messages of support.
Some, however, have also wondered how women can be "happy" to bleed since periods can often be pretty painful.
"We are using happy as a word to express sarcasm - as a satire, to taunt the authorities, the patriarchal forces which attach impurity with menstruation," Ms Azad explains.
"It may be painful, but it's perfectly normal to bleed and it does not make me impure," she adds.








3 PWD engineers suspended for dereliction in duty : Sanjay Patil

3 PWD engineers suspended for dereliction in duty : Sanjay Patil


Carpeting On Road 30mm By Pwd Department Himachal Pradesh - अब ...

Sanjay Patil : Nagpur Press Media : Shimla, May 22 (PTI) Three engineers of the Himachal Pradesh Public Works Department (HPPWD) have been suspended for dereliction in duty, an official spokesperson said on Friday.


The state government has placed under suspension the then Executive Engineer, HPPWD, Division Rohru and presently posted at Theog, Ravi Bhatti; Assistant Engineer, Rohru Narender Singh Naik; and Junior Engineer, Civil, HPPWD, Rohru Section Vijay Kumar, he said.

They are suspended for their negligence in proper supervision and monitoring in the construction of a double lane bridge over River Pabbar at Bakhirna in Shimla's Rohru subdivision, he said.

The under-construction bridge collapsed on May 13.

A three-member committee to inquire into the reasons of its collapse was set up on the directions of Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur.

In addition to technical shortcomings in construction of the bridge, negligence in proper supervision and monitoring was also pointed out in the findings of the committee, Principal Secretary, PWD, J C Sharma said.

A detailed inquiry in the matter was conducted and all these three engineers were found primarily responsible for this lapse, he added.

While the three officials have been put under suspension, show cause notices were being issued to remaining officers posted and associated with the said construction work, he added.

Thursday, 21 May 2020

जग बदलण्याची संधी :The Indian migrants dying to get home : Sanjay Patil

जग बदलण्याची संधी :The Indian migrants dying to get home : Sanjay Patil

MIgrants

Sanjay Patil : BBC: 22 May 2020 Nagpur News Media : Tens of thousands of daily-wage migrant workers suddenly found themselves without jobs or a source of income when India announced a lockdown on 24 March.
Overnight, the cities they had helped build and run seemed to have turned their backs on them, the trains and buses which should have carried them home suspended.
So with the looming fear of hunger, men, women and children were forced to begin arduous journeys back to their villages - cycling or hitching rides on tuk-tuks, lorries, water tankers and milk vans.
For many, walking was the only option. Some travelled for a few hundred kilometres, while others covered more than a thousand to go home.
They weren't always alone - some had young children and others had pregnant wives, and the life they had built for themselves packed into their ragtag bags.
Many never made it. Here, the BBC tells the story of just a handful of the hundreds who have lost their lives on the road home.
Sanju Yadav and her husband, Rajan, and their two children - Nitin and Nandini - arrived in India's financial capital, Mumbai, a decade ago with their meagre belongings and dreams of a brighter future.
Her children, she hoped, would thrive growing up in the city.
"It was not like she didn't like the village life," Rajan explained. "She just knew that Mumbai offered better opportunities for all of us."
Indeed, it was Sanju that encouraged Rajan to push himself.
"I used to do an eight-hour shift in a factory. Sanju motivated me do something more, so we bought a food cart and started selling snacks from 16:00 to 22:00.
"She pushed me to think big, she used to say that having our business was way better than a job. Job had a fixed salary, but business allowed us to grow."
Two years ago, all the hard work seemed to be paying off. Rajan used his savings and a bank loan to buy a tuk-tuk. The vehicle-for-hire brought more money for Sanju and her family.
But then came coronavirus.
The couple first heard Prime Minister Narendra Modi talk about the virus on TV on 19 March. A full, three-week lockdown was announced less than a week later.
They used up most of their savings to pay rent, repay the loan and buy groceries in March and April. They were hoping that the city would reopen in May, but then the lockdown was extended again.
Out of money and options, they decided to go back to their village in Jaunpur district in Uttar Pradesh state. They applied for tickets on the special trains that were being run for migrants, but had no luck for a week.
Desperate and exhausted, they decided to undertake the 1,500-km long journey in their tuk-tuk. The family-of-four left Mumbai on 9 May.
Rajan would drive from 05:00 to 11:00. He would then rest during the day, and at 18:00 the family would be back on the road until 23:00. "We ate whatever dry food we had packed and slept on pavements. The prospect of being in the safety of our village kept us going," he says.
But in the early hours of 12 May - just 200km from their village - a truck rammed into the tuk-tuk from behind.
Sanju and Nandini died on the spot. Rajan and Nitin escaped with minor injuries.
"It all ended so quickly," Rajan says. "We were so close to our village. We were so excited. But I have nothing left now - just a big void."
He says he can't help but keep thinking about the train tickets that never came. "I wish I had gotten the tickets. I wish I had never started the journey… I wish I was not poor."
Lallu Ram Yadav used to meet his cousin Ajay Kumar every Sunday to reminisce about the village he had left for Mumbai a decade earlier, in search of a better life for his wife and six children.
For 10 years, the 55-year-old had worked as a security guard, 12 hours a day, six days a week.
But his hard work amounted to little once the lockdown began, and the cousins both found their savings quickly ran out.
Lallu Ram called his family to say they were coming home - at least, he would now get to spend time with his children, he said.
And so Lallu Ram and Ajay Kumar joined the desperate scramble to find a way home to the village in Uttar Pradesh's Allahabad district, some 1,400km away.



But the price demanded by lorry drivers proved too much. Instead, inspired by the migrants walking home they saw on the television, they packed small bags and began the journey on foot with four friends.
The covered around 400km in the first 48 hours - hitchhiking in lorries along the way. But the journey was more difficult than they had imagined.
"It was really hot and we would get tired quickly," Ajay Kumar said. "The leather shoes we were wearing were extremely uncomfortable."
They all had blisters on their feet after walking for a day, but giving up was not an option.
One evening, Lallu Ram started complaining about breathing difficulties. They had just entered Madhya Pradesh state - they still had a long way to go, but they decided to rest for a while before starting again.
Lallu Ram never woke up. When they took him to a nearby hospital, they were told he had died of a cardiac arrest, triggered by exhaustion and fatigue.
hey didn't know what to do with the body. An ambulance was going to take five to eight hours to reach them.
The group had around 15,000 rupees ($199; £163) between them - half the amount needed to hire a lorry. But one driver agreed to take the rest of the payment later. And that's how they took the body back home.
Lallu Ram couldn't fulfil the promise of spending more time with his children.
"The family's only breadwinner is gone," says Ajay Kumar. "Nobody helped us. My cousin didn't have to die - but it was a choice between hunger and the long journey.
"We poor people often have to pick the best from several bad choices. It didn't work out for my cousin this time. It seldom works out for poor people like him."
Sagheer and Sahib Ansari were good tailors. They never struggled to find work in Delhi's booming garment factories - until the lockdown.
Within days, they lost their jobs. The brothers thought things would go back to normal in a few weeks and stayed put in their tiny one-room house.
When their money ran out, they asked family members in the village for help. When the lockdown was further extended in May, their patience ran out.
"We couldn't have asked the family for more money. We were supposed to help them, not take money from them," Sahib says.
They would wait in queues for food being distributed by the government. But, Sahib says, it was never enough and they always felt hungry.
So the brothers discussed the idea of going back to their village in Motihari district in Bihar state, some 1,200km from Delhi.
They and their friends decided to buy used bicycles, but could only afford six for eight people. So they decided that they would all take turns to ride pillion.
They left Delhi in the early hours of 5 May. It was a hot day and the group felt tired after every 10km.
"Our knees would hurt, but we kept pedalling. We hardly got a proper meal and that made it more difficult to pedal," Sahib says.
After riding for five days, the group reached Lucknow - the capital of Uttar Pradesh. It had been two days since they had had a proper meal and they were mostly surviving on puffed rice.
"All of us were very hungry. We sat on a road divider to eat because there was hardly any traffic," he says.
But then a car came out of nowhere, hitting the barrier and striking Sagheer. He died in a hospital a few hours later.
"My world came crashing down," Sahib says. "I had no idea what I was going to tell his two children and his wife.
"He used to love home-cooked food and was looking forward to it. He died without having a proper meal for days."
Sahib eventually reached home with his brother's body, brought by an ambulance. But he couldn't mourn with his family for long, as he was put into a quarantine centre right after the burial.
"I don't know who to blame for his death - coronavirus, hunger or poverty. I have understood one thing: I will never leave my village. I will make less money but at least I will stay alive."
Jaikrishna Kumar, 17, regrets encouraging his father Balram to come home after the lockdown started.
Balram was from a village in Bihar's Khagadia district, but was working in Gujarat - one of the states worst-hit by the coronavirus - when much of India closed down in March.
He and his friend Naresh Singh, a maintenance worker for mobile phone towers, were both working hard so their sons back in Bihar could have better futures. Balram wanted Jaikrishna to go to college, Nikram wanted his sons to become government officers.
They started their journey on foot, but about 400km into it, policemen helped them and others to hitch a ride in a lorry.
The "ride" involved them all being precariously perched on top of cargo - a common sight on Indian highways.
But this time, the driver lost control in Dausa town in Rajasthan state, ramming the lorry into a tree.
Both Naresh and Balram died in the accident.
Now Jaikrishna Kumar says he will probably have to quit studying and find a job to support the family.
"The accident took away my father and my dreams of getting an education. I wish there was another way. I don't like the idea of going to a city to work, but what other option do I have?
"My father wanted me to break the cycle of poverty. I don't know how to do it without him."
A migrant worker with his daughter
Many were travelling with small children
A group of migrants walking on a motorway
Many found it difficult to find food during their journeys
Sagheer Ansari's family in a file photo
An overcrowded lorry
Two migrants hanging on the back of a truckNaresh Singh's family photo





जगभर करोनाचं थैमान चालू असताना आपल्यासारख्या काही देशांमध्ये मोठं संकट उभं राहिलं आहे ते हे विस्थापनाचं! शहरा-महानगरांकडून गावांकडे, असं उलटं स्थलांतर..  टाळेबंदीमुळे रोजगार गेलेली आणि शहरांमध्ये राहणं अशक्य झालेली कुटुंबंच्या कुटुंब रस्त्यांवरून पायपीट करताना थकलेल्या लहान मुलांना उचलून घेऊन मैलोंगणती चाललीच आहेत.. आता, गावांमध्ये अनिश्चित काळापर्यंत राहावं लागणाऱ्या त्यातल्या बाईची अवस्था काय होईल?.. ती कशाकशाला सामोरी जाईल? शेती, शेतीआधारित उद्योग आणि संबंधित रोजगार क्षेत्राचं पुनरुज्जीवन हे यापुढच्या काळातलं सर्वात मोठं आव्हान आहे. जमिनीवरील, संसाधनांवरील स्त्रीच्या हक्काची लढाई इथून पुढच्या काळात जोरकस करावी लागणार आहे. विकासनीतीचा वेगळ्या अंगानं विचार करणं भाग झालेलं असताना हीच तिच्यासाठी एक नवी संधी ठरेल का?..
गालांमधलं बाळसंही अद्याप न सरलेली, आणि आता थकून, दमून गाढ झोपलेली छोटी मुलगी, अंगात विटका फ्रॉक आणि हातात चमकदार प्लास्टिकच्या बांगडय़ा घातलेली. त्या बांगडय़ा नक्कीच आईच्या मागे लागून घेतल्या असणार! उन्हा-वाऱ्यानं राठ झालेल्या, मळकटलेल्या झिपऱ्या तिच्या कपाळावर, गालांवर आल्या आहेत. चेहऱ्यावर विलक्षण श्रांत भाव. निव्वळ थकवा आणि गाढ झोप.. मिटलेले डोळे इतके भावदर्शी असतात?.. तिच्या पलीकडे तिला अगदी चिकटून झोपी गेलेली दुसरी आकृतीही आपल्याला दिसते. कृश, लाल साडीतली तिच्या शेजारी आडवी झालेली तिची आई. खरंतर ती आपल्याला दिसतच नाही, फक्त ती तिथे आहे हे जाणवतं. ती शेजारी आहे म्हणूनही ही इतकी निश्चिंत झोपली असावी..
सोबतच्या या छायाचित्राप्रमाणे गेल्या महिन्याभरात तुम्ही वर्तमानपत्रांमध्ये, दूरचित्रवाणीवरून, समाजमाध्यमांवरून  कितीतरी छायाचित्रं, दृश्य पाहिली असतील.. त्याजवळ थबकला असाल..
असंच आणखी एक दृश्य.. चाकांनी खेचण्याच्या भल्यामोठय़ा ट्रंकमध्ये आपला सगळा संसार भरून तो खेचत निघाली आहे ती बाई!  जुनी असली तरी चाकं शाबूत असलेल्या, मूळच्या निळ्या-हिरव्या पण आता विटलेल्या रंगाच्या त्या भल्यामोठय़ा बॅगवर तिचं चार-पाच वर्षांचं मूल थकून झोपी गेलंय. बॅगेची गाडी-गाडी करून खेळण्याऐवजी ते सर्व त्राण संपून गेलेलं मूल, ग्लानीत पडलंय त्या बॅगेवर. दोन्हीकडे हात-पाय टाकून. त्यामुळे, एरवी जी बॅग तिरकी धरून वजन न जाणवता खेचली गेली असती, ती सरळ ओढताना दमछाक होतेय त्या आईची. पण खेचून नेतेय ती. जिद्दीनं, निरुपायानं. माहीत नाही किती दूर.. कदाचित तिला माहीत असेल!
आणखी एक दृश्य.. चहुबाजूंनी भरत चाललेल्या ट्रकवर आपल्या वर्ष-दीड वर्षांच्या बाळाला बखोटीला धरून आत फेकण्यासाठी ट्रकला बांधलेल्या दोराला एका हातानं गच्च धरून एक बाबा धडपडतोय. वर त्या बाळाला घेण्यासाठी, नुसतं सुरक्षितपणे वर घेण्यासाठीही कुणी नाही. जो तो आपल्या घाईत, व्यवधानात, पाठमोरा. तरीही त्या बाबाला पर्याय नाहीये ते मूल तसंच वर टाकण्याला. बापानं पंजात धरलेल्या एका हाताशिवाय बाकीचं ते सर्व मूल हवेतच हेलकावतंय. खाली बाळाची आई उभी आहे. पूर्ण ‘अलर्ट’. चुकून बाबाच्या हातून ते निसटलंच तर त्याला झेलण्याची क्रिया तिच्याकडून प्रतिक्षिप्तपणे घडणार आहे..
आणखी एक आई, आपलं मूल कडेखांद्यावर घेऊन. शिवाय एक पिशवीही हातात घेऊन चाललीय.. स्वत:च्या वजनाइतकं वजन, तेही जिवंत वजन घेऊन चालतानाही तिचा वेग जाणवतोय. थकलेल्या मुलाला उचलून घेण्याशिवाय तिला पर्याय नाही, आणि आणखी किती मैलोंगणती चालायचंय हे आपल्याला माहीत नाही. पण तिची तातडी सांगतेय तिची घाई, काळजी, निरुपाय, कदाचित कुणी- पोलिसांनीही अडवण्याची भीतीसुद्धा!
अनेकांना त्या छायाचित्रांमागचं, दृश्यांमागचं विश्व जाणवलं असेल आणि काहींना पुढचं अंधारलेलं भविष्यही! तुमचाही जीव कळवळला असेल. तसे सहृदय असतो आपण! हे उघडय़ा डोळ्यांनी पाहण्याशिवाय आपण फारसं काही करू शकत नाही आहोत, याचा त्रास आपल्यालाही होतोय. आपणही त्रागा करतोय- या लोकांना असं चालावं लागण्याच्या स्थितीसाठी; सरकारी निर्ममता- अनेकदा अनास्था, चुकीचे निर्णय, पराकोटीचा धिमेपणा आणि ‘टिकमार्की’ वृत्तीसाठी! पण काही करू मात्र शकत नाही आहोत. केवळ जगता यावं यासाठी हजारो किलोमीटर चालून आपल्या ‘देस’ला निघालेल्या या लाखो- नव्हे, कोटय़वधी लोकांना थांबवू शकत नाही आहोत. मग ती सात महिन्यांची पोटुशी असो, सहा महिन्यांच्या बाळाला दुपटय़ात गुंडाळून वाशीपासून वाशिमपर्यंत कुटुंबासोबत निघालेली आई असो, की मुलाच्या खांद्यांवरून, आपल्या कृश, दुबळ्या हातांनी त्याला घट्ट धरून निघालेली ऐंशी पार केलेली म्हातारी!
पायी, कुठे सायकलींनी, कुठे ट्रक-टेम्पोंमध्ये कोंबून शहरांकडून गावांकडे निघालेल्या पहिल्या लोंढय़ांमध्ये बहुसंख्य पुरुषच होते. मुख्यत: ते पुरुष, ज्यांचं बायकापोरांसह सर्व कुटुंब आजही कुठल्यातरी दूरच्या खेडय़ात आहे. हजारो किलोमीटर दूरच्या. टाळेबंदीमुळे रोजगार थांबल्यानंतर इथे स्वत:चं आणि तिथे कुटुंबाचं पोट भरणं अशक्य झालेले हे पुरुष आपापल्या गावांकडे निघाले. त्यामुळेच, पहिल्या लोंढय़ांमध्ये मुख्यत: पुरुषच होते.
मात्र कुटुंबकबिल्यासह शहरा-महानगरांत स्थलांतरित आणि थोडेफार स्थायिक झालेले लाखो लोक, दुसऱ्या टप्प्यात जेव्हा बेरोजगारीमुळे, घरभाडंही भरता येत नसल्यामुळे शहरात राहणं अशक्य होऊन आपल्या मूळ गावांकडे निघाले, तेव्हा त्यांना कुटुंबासह जाणं भाग होतं. अशी हजारो कुटुंबं निघाली पायी चालत. पहिल्या टप्प्यात पायी चालणाऱ्या लोकांना गुन्हेगारासारखी वागणूक पोलीस आणि प्रशासनाकडून मिळाली. ती या टप्प्यात जरा निवळली होती. क्रमाक्रमानं बस, रेल्वेची सोय करण्यात येऊ लागली, परंतु ती अत्यंत अपुरी, बेभरवशाची आणि अनागोंदी स्वरूपाची असल्यामुळे संयम सुटलेल्या या लोकांनी मुलाबाळांसह चालत जाणं किंवा ट्रक-टेम्पोत कोंबून अत्यंत असुरक्षितपणे (बेकायदेशीरपणे, अनधिकृतपणे वगैरे) जाणं पत्करलं. नाशिकमधल्या एका अंदाजानुसार १ ते ८ मे दरम्यान केवळ  मुंबई-आग्रा महामार्गावरून दररोज १ लाख लोक पायी, सायकल, रिक्षा, टेम्पो, ट्रक, ट्रेलर यांनी गेले. शासकीय आकडेवारीनुसार टाळेबंदीच्या काळात निवारा हरवल्यामुळे निवासी छावण्यांमध्ये साडेसहा लाख लोक राहिले. महाराष्ट्रातून रेल्वेनं ३ लाख लोक, तर एसटीनं १ लाख लोक आपल्या गावी गेले. या सगळ्यात शासन-प्रशासनाचा जो निर्णयक्षमतेचा अभाव, अनास्था, दिरंगाई अनुभवाला आली त्यावर बरंच बोलण्यासारखं असलं तरी आता तो विषय नाहीये. आताचा विषय आहे तो या साऱ्या स्थितीचा स्त्रियांवर होणारा परिणाम!
मुळात मुलानं किंवा नवऱ्यानं रोजगारासाठी शहरात येण्याच्या निर्णयात त्याच्या आईचा, बायकोचा वाटा कितीसा असतो? खास करून बायकोचा. ‘माझी मैना गावाकडं राहिली, माझ्या जीवाची होतीया काहिली’, असं शाहीर म्हणतात आणि महानगरातल्या एकटय़ा पुरुषाच्या दु:खाला वाट करून देतात. गावाकडं राहिलेल्या त्याच्या बायकोच्या स्थितीबद्दल कोण काय बोलतं? तिला भावना, वासना, शरीरधर्म नसतात? (आठवा, ‘गमन’!)  तसंच, शहरांकडून पुन्हा गावाकडे निघण्याचा निर्णय या पोटात, कडेवर, हाताशी पोरं असलेल्या कुटुंबात कोण घेत असेल? बाईचा त्या निर्णयात काही वाटा असेल? असता, तर तिनं हा निर्णय मान्य केला असता?.. आता, गावांमध्ये अनिश्चित काळापर्यंत राहावं लागणाऱ्या या बाईची अवस्था काय असेल? तिच्या बेरोजगार नवऱ्याचं ‘स्टेटस’, ते तिचं ‘स्टेटस’. आणि ती स्वत: तर कायमचीच बेरोजगार! कसं निभवेल? कशाकशाला सामोरी जाईल?
ग्रामीण भागाची कितीही सुंदर वर्णनं केली, तरी तिथलं आयुष्य सुंदर राहिलेलं नाही ही वस्तुस्थिती आहे. तरीही ग्रामीण भागातली स्त्री ही शहरी कष्टकरी वर्गातल्या स्त्रीपेक्षा अधिक थेटपणे आर्थिक व्यवहाराशी जोडली गेली आहे ती तिच्या शेतीतल्या सहभागामुळे. शेतीत (कायदे होऊनही) अधिकार नसले आणि निर्णयामध्ये ज्याला आपण इंग्रजीत ‘से’ म्हणतो तो नसला, तरी सर्वाधिक कष्ट स्त्रीचेच आहेत. परंतु आता, शहरातील कुटुंबीय परत गावी आल्यानंतर तिच्या या सहभागाचं नेमकं काय होणार ते पाहिलं पाहिजे.
खास करून ग्रामीण भागातल्या स्त्रिया जवळपासच्या छोटय़ा उद्योगांमध्ये, कंपन्यांमध्ये कामाला जातात. हे उद्योग आता बंद पडल्यामुळे त्या बेरोजगार झाल्या आहेत. या संदर्भात एक आकडेवारी अतिशय बोलकी आहे. ‘पिरिऑडिकल लेबर फोर्स सव्‍‌र्हे’च्या २०१७-१८ च्या आकडेवारीनुसार शेती व शेतीबाह्य़ अनौपचारिक ग्रामीण रोजगारांत स्त्रियांची भागीदारी ५४.८ टक्के आहे. शेतीबाह्य़ क्षेत्रात, जिथे नियमित स्वरूपाची पगारी नोकरी असते, तिथे ७१.१ टक्के कामगारांशी कुठल्याही प्रकारचं नोकरीचं कंत्राट झालेलं नसतं. अशा नोकऱ्यांमध्ये स्त्रियांचं प्रमाण ६६.८ टक्के आहे. ५० टक्क्यांहून अधिक स्त्री कामगारांना पगारी रजा अथवा सामाजिक सुरक्षिततेचे कुठलेही फायदे मिळत नाहीत. ग्रामीण मिळवत्या स्त्रीचं मासिक उत्पन्न चार ते साडेआठ हजार रुपये असतं. रोजगार हमीवर तर त्याहूनही कमी, तेदेखील वर्षांकाठी जास्तीतजास्त १०० दिवस. ही २०१७-१८ ची आकडेवारी आहे. स्त्रियांमधल्या बेरोजगारीचं प्रमाण दरवर्षी वाढतं आहे. आता सर्व रोजगार ठप्प झाल्यानंतर या तुटपुंज्याही उत्पन्नाचं काय झालं असेल याचा आपण अंदाज करू शकतो.
कुटुंबांतल्या म्हाताऱ्यांचं स्थान तसंही उपेक्षितच असतं. आता कुटुंबात येणारा पैसा थांबल्यामुळे त्या अधिक दुर्लक्षित होतील.
‘करोना’मुळे बेरोजगार झालेल्यांत वेश्या व्यवसाय करणाऱ्या स्त्रियाही आहेत. त्यांना तर परत जायला ‘देस’च नाही!
मोठा गाजावाजा करून सरकारनं दारूची दुकानं उघडली. ती उघडल्यावर ‘सेफ डिस्टन्सिंग’ धुडकावून त्यांच्यापुढे लागलेल्या रांगा टीव्हीवर दाखवल्या गेल्या. त्या रांगांमध्ये बायकाही आहेत हे आवर्जून दाखवलं आणि त्यांच्यासाठी वेगळी रांग लावावी लागत आहे हेदेखील. ‘सेफ डिस्टन्सिंग’चा फज्जा उडाला तेव्हा घरपोच दारूची जाहिरात करण्यात आली. जणू दारू ही जीवनावश्यक वस्तूच आहे!  ‘परिवर्तन’ संस्थेची आकडेवारी असं सांगते, की टाळेबंदीच्या काळात व्यसनमुक्तीचं प्रमाण ५० टक्क्यांनी वाढलं होतं. त्याचबरोबर पैशांची बचत आणि व्यसन कमी झाल्यानं कौटुंबिक स्वास्थ्य काही प्रमाणात सुधारलं होतं.  दारूमुळे मिळणारा महसूल या फायद्यांपेक्षा अधिक होता का?, की सर्व लाभहानी केवळ पैशांतच मोजायची?  कष्टकरी वर्गातल्या स्त्रियांचा सर्वात मोठा शत्रू दारू हा आहे. तिच्या कमाईचा मोठा भाग नवऱ्याच्या दारूत आणि त्यापायी उद्भवणारे आजार काढण्यात जातो, शिवाय दररोज त्याच्या मारहाणीचा सामना करावा लागतो तो वेगळाच. अशा वेळी म्हणजे टाळेबंदीच्या काळात दारू पिण्यात घट झालेली असताना  दारूविक्री सुरू करण्याचं आणि आमिष दाखवल्याप्रमाणे या निर्णयाची जाहिरातही करण्याचं कारण काय?
टाळेबंदीचा कौटुंबिक स्वास्थ्यावर झालेला सर्वाधिक परिणाम बाईलाच भोगावा लागतो आहे. मग ती कष्टकरी वर्गातली असो वा ‘बौद्धिक’ श्रम करणाऱ्या बुद्धिजीवी वर्गातली. फक्त कष्टकरी वर्गापुरतं बोलायचं झालं, तर शहरात राहणाऱ्यांना अपुरी जागा, अन्नासारख्या जीवनावश्यक वस्तूंचा अभाव, शाळा-महाविद्यालयं- रोजगार बंद असल्यामुळे चोवीस तास मुलांचं घरात असणं, त्यांची अस्वस्थता, चिडचिड, जोडीदाराची आणि स्वत:चीही लैंगिक घुसमट या सगळ्याला बाई सामोरी जाते आहे. ज्या घरात ‘शिफ्ट’नंच राहावं लागतं तिथे जर एकाच वेळी कुटुंबातल्या वा समूहातल्या सर्व माणसांना राहायची वेळ आली, तर ते राहणार तरी कुठे आणि कसं पाळणार सुरक्षित अंतर? आधीच घरी राहणाऱ्या स्त्रीला- जी काहीच काम करत नाही, असंच मानलं जातं आणि तिची स्वत:ची काहीच कमाई नसल्यामुळे तसाही तिला काही हक्क नसतोच- उसंत नसते. आता तर घरातली अन्य माणसं घराबाहेर असण्याच्या काळात तिला मिळणारा उरलासुरला मोकळा वेळही हिरावला गेला आहे आणि उलट सर्व माणसं सर्व वेळ घरात असल्यामुळे त्यांची करावी लागणारी उस्तवारी वाढली आहे. घरातल्या ‘कर्त्यां’ पुरुषाचा रोजगार हरवल्यामुळे अर्थातच बाईच्या- मग ती घरात राहणारी असो, किंवा बाहेर जाऊन कमावणारी, तिनं पै-पै करून साठवलेल्या बचती- ज्या साधारणपणे कुटुंबाच्याच अडीअडचणीला, मुलांच्या शिक्षण-पोषणासाठी खर्च केल्या जातात, त्या संपुष्टात येतील.
ही नुसती शब्दचित्रं नाहीत. वर्णनं नाहीत. आकडे नाहीत. ही एक स्थिती आहे. आजच्या काळाची स्थिती! आपल्या देशातली स्थिती. जगभर करोनाचं थैमान चालू असताना आणि अमेरिका, इटलीसारख्या बडय़ा देशांना त्या महामारीनं जेरीला आणलेलं असताना आपल्या आणि आपल्यासारख्या अन्य काही देशांमध्ये मात्र करोना महामारीपेक्षा मोठं संकट उभं झालं आहे ते हे विस्थापनाचं. अभूतपूर्व विस्थापन! हे विस्थापन रोजगारांतून आहे आणि विशेष म्हणजे शहरा-महानगरांकडून गावांकडे असं उलटं विस्थापन- किंवा स्थलांतर हा शब्द अधिक योग्य- ते आहे. देशाची, जगाचीही सर्व आर्थिक घडी या करोनानं विस्कटून टाकली आहेच, परंतु आपल्यासारख्या देशांसाठी तर ती फार उलटीपालटी झाली आहे.
करोनाचा मुख्य दणका बसलाय तो महानगरांना आणि महानगरीय व्यवस्थेला! बरं, हा दणका काही तात्पुरता नाही. करोना आणि त्यानंतर त्याचे आणखीही भयानक भाऊबंद येऊ शकतील. त्या साथींना तोंड द्यायचं असेल तर विलगीकरण हा उपाय नसला तरी त्यावर लस तयार होईपर्यंत तेवढाच पर्याय असेल, आणि विलगीकरण हे आजच्या महानगरीय व्यवस्थेत शक्य नाही. कारण ही महानगरीय व्यवस्थाच मुळी तिथल्या झोपडपट्टय़ांमधून वसलेल्या स्वस्त श्रम पुरवणाऱ्या श्रमिकांवर अवलंबून असते. तंत्रज्ञानाच्या आधारे ‘मनुष्यविहीन’ (म्हणजे ‘श्रमिक समूहविहीन’) अशी महानगरं पुढच्या काळात वसतीलही कदाचित, पण त्या वेळी हा एवढा प्रचंड श्रमिक वर्ग कुठे जाणार, कुठे राहणार, काय कमवणार, कसा जगणार, हे सारे प्रश्न निर्माण होतील. त्यांची उत्तरं त्या वेळचे धोरणकर्ते काय काढतात त्यावर भारतातील या श्रमिकांचं भवितव्य अवलंबून असणार आहे. अधिकाधिक यांत्रिकीकरण, मानवविरहित तंत्रज्ञानाकडे वाटचाल झाली, तर मोठा मानवी समूह रोजगारापासून वंचित स्थितीत गावागावांमध्ये विखरून पडेल. गावांमधल्या स्वायत्त, स्वावलंबी व्यवस्था आपण केव्हाच मोडून काढल्या आहेत. शेतीही या अतिरिक्त लोकसंख्येचा भार सोसू शकणार नाही. आणि त्यामुळे पर्यायांचा विचार करताना पुढील काळातील अर्थव्यवस्थेत या श्रमिकांचं स्थान काय, याचा विचार करावाच लागणार आहे. श्रमिक, यामध्ये स्त्रिया आणि पुरुष, दोन्ही आले.
अशा वेळी, जेव्हा गमावण्यासारखं काहीच राहिलेलं नाही, तेव्हा वेगळा विचार करण्याचीही शक्यता निर्माण होते आणि राज्यकर्त्यांनी केला- न केला, तरी समाजानं तो करायची आणि त्या दिशेनं जाण्यास राज्यकर्त्यांना भाग पाडायची वेळ आली आहे. नाहीतर समाजाचा मोठा हिस्सा केवळ ‘कॉर्पोरेट्स’चा गुलाम बनून जाण्याचा धोका आहे. त्यात सर्वात तळाला असणार आहे ती बाई!
तर मग, आजही या समाजाच्या, त्यातल्या बाईच्याही हातात काय काय आहे, असू शकतं? आजही शेती आहे. शेतीचा एकूण राष्ट्रीय उत्पन्नातला वाटा कितीही नगण्य दाखवला जात असला तरी शेती हे सर्वात महत्त्वाचं क्षेत्र आहे- जीवनावश्यक म्हणूनही आणि रोजगाराचं क्षेत्र म्हणूनही. नोटा किंवा ‘सिलिकॉन चिप्स’ खाऊन जिवंत राहता येत नाही, हे आपण या टाळेबंदीच्या काळात चांगलंच अनुभवलं आहे. तेव्हा या शेती, शेतीआधारित उद्योग आणि तदनुषंगिक रोजगार क्षेत्राचं पुनरुज्जीवन करणं हे पुढील काळातलं सर्वात मोठं आव्हान राहणार आहे, आणि तीच संधीही असणार आहे. पुन्हा एकदा त्यावर आधारित गृहोद्योग, कुटिरोद्योग आणि ग्रामोद्योगांचा विचार आणि त्यांना विशेष सवलती, सोयी-सुविधा आणि अर्थातच भाव देऊन शाश्वतता प्रदान करणं आवश्यक आहे. यामध्ये मोठं योगदान- औपचारिक वा अनौपचारिक- बाईचं असणार आहे.
शेतीच्या पलीकडे अजून जे काही टिकून आहे, ते जल आणि जंगल- ज्यावर आजही मोठय़ा प्रमाणावर समाज जगतो आहे, आणि त्याला तिथून बेदखल करण्याचा सतत प्रयत्न होतो आहे. समुद्र आणि नद्यांमधली मासळी हा मोठय़ा समूहाचा जीवनाधार आहे. जंगलातल्या लाकूडफाटय़ापासून तर तेंदू, मोहासह अनेक वनौपजांद्वारे आजही मोठय़ा प्रमाणावर आदिवासी आणि जंगलांच्या आधारानं राहणारे समाज जगत आहेत. वनअधिकार कायद्यासारखे काही पुरोगामी कायदे झाले, परंतु ते काढून घेण्याचा प्रयत्न राज्यकर्ता वर्ग सतत करत आहे आणि दुसरीकडे या समूहांना त्या संसाधनांवर हक्कच काय, तिथपर्यंत ते पोहोचणारही नाहीत, असेच कायदे करून, अथवा न करताही ही संसाधनं ताब्यात घेऊ बघतो आहे. हे आक्रमण थोपवावं लागेल आणि स्थानिक संसाधनांवर स्थानिकांचा पहिला हक्क आग्रहपूर्वक मागावा आणि मिळवावा लागेल. मागच्या ३०-३५ वर्षांमध्ये असा हक्क मागणारी जी शांततामय आंदोलनं झाली, होत आहेत, त्यामध्ये स्त्रियांचा सहभाग सर्वाधिक राहिला आहे आणि त्यांचा चिवटपणा सतत दिसून आला आहे. आपली जमीन, संसाधनं सोडायला पुरुष जितका सहजपणे तयार होतो तशी स्त्री होत नाही असा अनुभव आहे. म्हणूनच, जमिनीवरील, संसाधनांवरील स्त्रीच्या हक्काचीही लढाई इथून पुढच्या काळात जोरकस करावी लागणार आहे.
अर्थातच हे पुरेसं नाही. परंतु विकासाची दिशा बदलली तर अनेक पर्याय दिसू लागणार आहेत, उपलब्ध होणार आहेत. ‘भूक आणि हाव’ यातला फरक माणसाला करावाच लागणार आहे, आणि प्रच्छन्न उपभोगाकडून ‘साधी राहणी’कडे वळावं लागणार आहे. हाच इशारा करोनानं दिला आहे. आता त्या दिशेनं विचार सुरू करायला हवा आहे- अगदी आपल्या वैयक्तिक जीवनातल्या परावलंबित्वापासून तर समाजा-देशा-जगाच्या प्राधान्यक्रम आणि जीवनपद्धतींपर्यंत!
पुढच्या काळात करोनासारख्या साथींबरोबरच पूर आणि दुष्काळाचं दुष्टचक्र अपेक्षित आहे. हा सारा हवामानबदलाचा परिणाम आहे, असणार आहे; आणि आजवर अनेक वैज्ञानिक वारंवार ओरडून सांगत असतानाही तो इशारा धुडकावून विनाशकारी विकासचक्र फिरवणाऱ्या सर्वानाच- भांडवलदार वर्ग आणि शासक वर्ग यांना करोना संकटानं मोठाच तडाखा दिला आहे. त्यानं ते जागे झाले तर ठीक, नाहीतर त्यांना जागं करावं लागेल. टाळेबंदीमुळे प्रदूषणकारी उद्योगधंदे, वाहनं थांबल्यामुळे पृथ्वीवरचं आकाश स्वच्छ झालं आहे. कदाचित पृथ्वीच्या नाशाकडे टिकटिकत जाणाऱ्या घडय़ाळाची गतीही थोडी मंदावली असेल.  जे बर्नी सँडर्सपासून ग्रेटा थनबर्गपर्यंत आणि मेधा पाटकरांपासून वंदना शिवांपर्यंत कित्येकांनी ओरडून सांगून जगाला ऐकू गेलं नाही, ते एका करोना नावाच्या सूक्ष्मजीवानं करून दाखवलं आहे! जगाला विकासाविषयी पुनर्विचार करायला भाग पाडलं आहे.
शाश्वत अशा पर्यायी विकासनीतीची संकल्पना अनेकांनी मांडली आहे. साधनसंपत्तीची लूट अथवा विनाश न करता, विकसनशील रीतीनं तिचा उपयोग करत, त्या संपत्तीचं समतेच्या आधारावर वितरण व्हावं अशी ती ढोबळमानानं कल्पना आहे. हे जे जग आपल्याला मिळालं आहे, ते आपल्या उपभोगासाठी ओरबाडून संपवण्यासाठी नसून जपून पुढील पिढय़ांच्या हाती ठेवण्यासाठी आहे, ही भूमिका त्यामागे आहे. गांधीजींचा सर्वोदयाचा आणि अंत्योदयाचा विचार त्यामध्ये आहे, आणि अंतिम माणसाच्या शेवटच्या पायरीवर बाई उभी आहे. पर्यायी विकासनीतीचा विचार हा स्त्रीवादी विचाराशी म्हणूनच मिळताजुळता आहे. त्यामध्ये स्थानिकता आहे, विकेंद्रित रोजगाराच्या शक्यता आहेत, आत्मसन्मान आणि समता आहे, परस्परावलंबन आहे. त्यातून येणारी स्वयंपूर्णता आहे. आज अर्थव्यवस्थेच्या परिघावर लोटल्या गेलेल्या आणि अर्थव्यवस्थेत सर्वात कळीचा घटक असलेल्या श्रमिकाला सन्मानानं जगण्याची ती हमी आहे. कुटुंब आणि जीवनशैली या दोन्ही स्तरांवर विकासनीतीचा पुनर्विचार आपल्याला करावा लागणार आहे, आणि हा विचार पर्यावरणीय स्त्रीवादाच्या दिशेनं जातो.
शेतीचा शोध लावणारी बाई हे संक्रमण करेल. ती सर्जनशक्ती  आणि जग जगवण्याची प्रेरणा तिच्यात आहे. तो विश्वास तिला दिला पाहिजे. ती प्रेरणा जागवली पाहिजे. बाकी कशासाठी नाही, तर आपल्या कच्च्याबच्च्यांसाठी ती नक्की उभी राहील आणि नवं जग घडवेल.
आपण तिच्या पाठीशी राहू या!

ऑनलाईन ‘लेसन’ ऐवजी पोटासाठी रेशन द्या!


शिक्षण विभागाकडून विद्यार्थ्यांकरिता सुरू करण्यात आलेल्या ‘लर्न फ्रॉम होम’ उपक्रमाबाबत ग्रामीण भागातील पालकांकडून संताप व्यक्त होत असून ‘ऑनलाईन ‘लेसन’ नको तर पोटासाठी रेशन द्या’अशी मागणी ग्रामीण भागातील पालकांकडून केली जात आहे.
करोनाच्या प्रादुर्भावामुळे संपूर्ण जीवनमान विस्कळीत झाले आहे. लोकांचा रोजगार बंद असून उदरनिर्वाहासाठी धडपड सुरू आहे. एकूणच लोकांना जगण्यासाठी संघर्ष करावा लागत आहे. ग्रामीण भागातील जीवनाचे असे विदारक चित्र असताना दुसरीकडे मात्र, शिक्षण विभागाकडून विद्यार्थ्यांसाठी ‘लर्न फ्रॉम होम’ उपक्रमाचा अट्टाहास सुरू आहे. विद्यार्थ्यांचे व्हॉटसअ‍ॅप ग्रुप तयार करून त्यामाध्यमातून अभ्यास देणे, त्यावर आधारित प्रश्नपत्रिका सोडवून घेणे इत्यादी बाबी करून घेतल्या जात आहे. हे सर्व कमी की काय म्हणून रेडिओवरचे कार्यक्रम ऐकण्याबाबतही विद्यार्थ्यांना सक्ती केली जात आहे. सुरुवातीला या उपक्रमाबाबत आढावा घेतला जात नव्हता परंतु, आता त्याबाबतचा आढावा घेणे सुरू झाल्याने शिक्षकही पालकांना वारंवार फोन करून विद्यार्थ्यांबाबत माहिती जाणून घेत आहेत. त्यामुळे ग्रामीण पालक अधिकच त्रस्त होत असून गुरुजी, आम्हाला जगू द्या, सध्या आमच्यासाठी तेच महत्त्वाचे आहे. आज जगलो तर उद्या शिकता येईल. आमच्या लेकरांचा एवढाच कळवळा असेल तर या तुमच्या ऑनलाईन लेसन ऐवजी त्याच्यासाठी थोडे रेशन पाठवायला तुमच्या सरकारला सांगा, असा संताप व्यक्त केला जात आहे.  काही ठिकाणी यावरून शिक्षक व पालकात वाक्युद्ध रंगल्याचेही उदाहरण पहायला मिळत आहेत. हे थांबले नाही तर या उपक्रमावरून शिक्षक व पालकात संघर्ष निर्माण होण्याची संभावना नाकारता येत नाही.

कांग्रेस को मायावती ने खूब सुनाया :  संजय पाटिल

कांग्रेस को मायावती ने खूब सुनाया : संजय पाटिल

मायावती (फाइल फोटो)
लखनऊ : संजय पाटिल :  नागपुर प्रेस मीडिया : 22 मई 2020 : (एजेंसी) :  उत्तर प्रदेश में कांग्रेस और योगी सरकार के बीच बस पॉलिटिक्स ठंडी ही पड़नी शुरू हुई थी 
राजस्थान सरकार ने यूपी सरकार को बसों का बिल थमाकर इसे फिर से तूल दे दिया। 36 लाख के इस बिल पर अब सियासत तेज होने लगी है। खास बात यह है कि उत्तर प्रदेश के पूर्व मुख्यमंत्री और बहुजन समाज पार्टी की मुखिया मायावती भी खुलकर बीजेपी के समर्थन में उतरी हैं। मायावती ने ट्वीट करके कांग्रेस को जमकर खरी-खोटी सुनाई है।

मायावती ने राजस्थान पर घिनौनी राजनीति करने का आरोप लगाया है। उन्होंने ट्वीट किया, 'राजस्थान की कांग्रेसी सरकार द्वारा कोटा से करीब 12000 युवा-युवतियों को वापस उनके घर भेजने पर हुए खर्च के रूप में यूपी सरकार से 36.36 लाख रुपये और देने की जो मांग की है वह उसकी कंगाली और अमानवीयता को प्रदर्शित करता है। दो पड़ोसी राज्यों के बीच ऐसी घिनौनी राजनीति अति-दुखःद है।'

इतना ही नहीं मायावती ने दूसरा ट्वीट करके कांग्रेस के कृत्य को अमानवीय बताया। उन्होंने लिखा, 'कांग्रेसी राजस्थान सरकार एक तरफ कोटा से यूपी के छात्रों को अपनी कुछ बसों से वापस भेजने के लिए मनमाना किराया वसूल रही है तो दूसरी तरफ अब प्रवासी मजदूरों को यूपी में उनके घर भेजने के लिए बसों की बात करके जो राजनीतिक खेल खेल कर रही है यह कितना उचित और कितना मानवीय?'

इससे पहले मायावती ने ट्वीट किया था कि कांग्रेस बस की राजनीति करने के बजाए श्रमिकों को ट्रेनों से भेजे। उन्होंने लिखा था कि कांग्रेस को श्रमिक प्रवासियों को बसों से ही घर भेजने में मदद करने पर अड़ने की बजाए, इनका टिकट लेकर ट्रेनों से ही इन्हें इनके घर भेजने में इनकी मदद करनी चाहिए तो यह ज्यादा उचित और सही होगा।


बहुजन समाज पार्टी सुप्रीमो मायावती ने शुक्रवार को कहा कि देश में कोरोना वायरस वैश्विक महामारी को फैलने से रोकने के लिए लगाए लॉकडाउन के कारण बेरोजगार और बेआसरा हो गए करोड़ों प्रवासी श्रमिक परिवारों की जो दुःखद एवं शर्मनाक दुर्दशा हर जगह देखने को मिल रही है उसकी असली कसूरवार कांग्रेस पार्टी ही मानी जाएगी। उन्होंने कहा कि आजादी के बाद केन्द्र और राज्यों में कांग्रेस के लम्बे शासनकाल के दौरान अगर गांव एवं शहरों में लोगों की रोजी-रोटी की सही व्यवस्था की गई होती तो इन्हें दूसरे राज्यों में क्यों पलायन करने को मजबूर होना पड़ता
? यहां जारी एक बयान में उन्होंने कहा कि वर्तमान समय में भी कांग्रेसी नेताओं द्वारा कुछ श्रमिकों का दुःख-दर्द बांटने संबंधी जो वीडियो दिखाये जा रहे हैं वह इनकी हमदर्दी कम और नाटक ज्यादा लगता है। अगर कांग्रेस पार्टी इस समय यह बताती कि उसने उन पीड़ितों से मिलते समय कितने लोगों की असल में मदद की तो यह बेहतर होता। मायावती ने कहा कि ऐसे विकट समय में उनका भाजपा की केन्द्र तथा राज्य सरकारों से भी यह कहना है कि वे कांग्रेस पार्टी के पदचिन्हों पर न चलकर घर वापसी कर रहे मजदूरों को उनके गांवों तथा शहरों में ही रोजी-रोटी की सही व्यवस्था करके उन्हें आत्मनिर्भर बनाने की नीति पर अगर ईमानदारी से अमल करती है तो फिर आगे ऐसी दुर्दशा इन्हें शायद कभी नहीं झेलनी पड़ेगी।

उन्होंने बसपा के कार्यकर्ताओं से भी पुनः अपील की कि जिन प्रवासी मजदूरों को उनके घर लौटने पर उन्हें गाँवों से दूर अलग-थलग रखा गया है तथा उन्हें उचित सरकारी मदद नहीं मिल पा रही है तो ऐसे लोगों की मानवीय मदद करने का प्रयास करें क्योंकि पीड़ित ही पीड़ित का दर्द समझ कर एक-दूसरे की सही मदद कर सकता है।